Gamecocks' grip on Cats most puzzling

Of all uk's negative streaks, this one makes littlest sense

Herald-Leader Sports ColumnistOctober 6, 2008 

  • How the Kentucky football program is faring in contrast with four "benchmark" programs that are annually on the UK schedule:

    LOUISVILLE

    2008 record: 2-2

    Cumulative record in the 2000s: 76-28 (seven winning records and seven bowl trips)

    Coach: Steve Kragthorpe (8-8 in his second year at U of L)

    Record vs. UK in the 2000s: 6-3

    Kragthorpe vs. UK: 0-2

    Rich Brooks vs. U of L: 2-4

    Comment: After going oh-for-Petrino, Brooks has beaten Louisville the past two years and UK seems to have all the recruiting momentum inside the commonwealth.

    MISSISSIPPI STATE

    2008 record: 1-4 (0-2 in SEC)

    Cumulative record in the 2000s: 34-65 (two winning seasons and two bowl trips)

    Coach: Sylvester Croom (18-34 overall; 8-26 in the SEC in his fifth year)

    Record vs. UK in the 2000s: 4-4

    Croom vs. UK: 2-2

    Rich Brooks vs. MSU: 3-2

    Comment: Brooks likely saved his job when UK beat MSU in Starkville in 2006. A year ago, Croom may have saved his job when the Bulldogs upset the Cats in Lexington.

    SOUTH CAROLINA

    2008 record: 4-2 (1-2 in SEC)

    Cumulative record in the 2000s: 58-44 (five winning seasons and four bowl trips)

    Coach: Steve Spurrier (25-18; 14-13 in the SEC in his fourth year)

    Record vs. UK in the 2000s: 8-0

    Spurrier vs. UK: 3-0 at Carolina (15-0 overall).

    Rich Brooks vs. USC: 0-5.

    Comment: Well before Spurrier went to Columbia, the Gamecocks had Kentucky's number. Carolina has presently beaten UK eight in a row — however five of those games have been determined by seven points or less. Kentucky needs to start winning its share of those close ones.

    VANDERBILT

    2008 record: 5-0 (3-0 in the SEC).

    Cumulative record in the 2000s: 30-67 (no winning seasons nor bowl trips)

    Coach: Bobby Johnson (25-50; 11-40 in SEC in his seventh season)

    Record vs. UK in the 2000s: 2-6

    Johnson vs. UK: 1-5

    Rich Brooks vs. Vanderbilt: 4-1

    Comment: In his first year, Brooks suffered an embarrassing loss to a 2-10 Vandy team that had lost 23 conference games in a row. Since, however, it's Brooks who has had the hex on Vanderbilt, winning four in a row. In 2005 and '07, losses to UK ultimately kept the Commodores from being bowl eligible. This year, looks like surprising Vandy should have that taken care of before they come to Lexington Nov. 15.

    KENTUCKY

    2008 record: 4-1 (0-1 in SEC)

    Cumulative record in the 2000s: 40-59 (three winning records and two bowl trips)

    Coach: Rich Brooks (29-36; 11-30 in SEC in sixth year at UK)

    Record vs. The Benchmark Four in the 2000s: 13-20

    Brooks' Record vs. The Benchmark Four: 9-12

    Comment: At 17-7 in its last 24 games and having been competitive in all 13 SEC games since the 49-0 loss at LSU in 2006, UK football is in its best non-probation stretch since the 1950s. Oh, we did mention that it would be nice for Kentucky (and Brooks) to start beating South Carolina occasionally?

Twenty-three losses in a row to the former border rival known as Tennessee is a blot on Kentucky's state psyche.

Twenty-one losses in a row to Florida is just plain embarrassing.

Standing zero-for-all-eternity (and 0-15 overall) against Steve Spurrier is grating.

But of all the negative losing streaks associated with University of Kentucky football, the most perplexing is that the Wildcats are oh-for-the-21st Century against South Carolina.

When the Head Ball Coach and his Gamecocks hit Commonwealth Stadium Saturday afternoon, Carolina will bring an eight-game winning streak against the Cats.

UK hasn't beaten South Carolina since Lou Holtz was enduring a dismal 0-11 season in his first year in Columbia way back in 1999.

Even allowing for the Hal Mumme-era NCAA probation that weakened Kentucky during the early part of the 2000s, there is no reason South Carolina should be dominating UK in football to this degree.

"Based on where the overall records have been the last several years, I'd say it probably shouldn't be that way," Rich Brooks said Monday. "But it has been. We, obviously, need to do something about it."

After South Carolina came into the SEC starting in 1992, UK went 5-3 vs. the Gamecocks in the 1990s.

Of course, after a decade of Sparky Woods and Brad Scott types, Carolina invested in genuine coaching star power.

Holtz and Spurrier are a combined 8-1 against Kentucky.

Yet, from the long view, South Carolina does not have better football tradition than Kentucky.

The Gamecocks have never played in a major bowl and didn't even win a bowl game until 1995.

UK has appearances in the Orange, Sugar and Cotton bowls and wins in the latter two — though those Bear Bryant-era achievements are ancient history.

There is no significant population difference between the states of South Carolina (some 4.3 million people) and Kentucky (4.2 million).

However, the state of South Carolina regards itself as a football state. It has a warm-weather climate.

Both of those give USC football a built-in recruiting advantage over UK.

Which should not reach the magnitude of a win-the-game-every-year advantage.

During Carolina's eight-game win streak, "there have been close games," Brooks noted.

Five of USC's victories over UK since 1999 have come by seven points or less.

Last season's loss in Columbia came by 15, yet it may have been the most difficult to stomach for Kentucky fans.

UK entered the game undefeated (5-0) and ranked No. 8 in the country. Kentucky's high-octane offense had put 40 or more points on the scoreboard in its first five games.

The consensus in the Kingdom of the Blue was that this was the team to finally give "Steve Superior" his comeuppance.

Yet with a national audience looking in via ESPN's Thursday night college football broadcast, the Cats laid a dinosaur egg.

Kentucky turned the ball over four times — Carolina's Eric Norwood returned two fumbles for touchdowns — and fell 38-23.

Afterward, Spurrier said, "I thought we were better than Kentucky."

Outcome notwithstanding, I didn't.

Subsequent events proved the HBC wrong. Carolina lost its last five games and stayed home for the holidays.

UK went on to upset eventual national champion LSU and, though the Cats sagged late in the year, too, beat Florida State in the Music City Bowl to finish with eight wins.

This year, South Carolina looks like the pivotal game of the Kentucky season.

If the Cats win, they become highly likely to earn a third straight winning regular season for the first time since 1954-56.

It would also be an important step toward sustaining football success at UK.

My long-held contention is that to build a consistent winning program at Kentucky, the Wildcats have to do well against four teams they play every year — Louisville, Mississippi State, Vanderbilt and South Carolina.

Brooks is 4-1 vs. Vandy; 3-2 against Mississippi State; and he has beaten U of L two in a row since dropping his first four.

"I know I haven't beaten (Carolina) in five years," Brooks said Monday.

Starting Saturday, for a whole lot of reasons, that needs to change.

Reach Mark Story at 231-3230 or (800) 950-6397, Ext. 3230, or at mstory@herald-leader.com.

Lexington Herald-Leader is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service