Mark Story: UK football must find success against 'Benchmark Four'

Herald-Leader Sports ColumnistJuly 5, 2012 

  • The Cats vs. The 'Benchmark Four'

    How Kentucky's football program stacks up against four benchmark foes who are annually on the UK schedule:


    2011 record: 5-7

    Record since 2006: 41-36 (16-32 SEC)

    Coach: Joker Phillips (11-14 in two years)

    Record vs. "Benchmark Four" since 2006: 11-13

    Record vs. "Benchmark Four" in 2000s: 19-29

    Joker Phillips vs. "Benchmark Four: 3-5

    Comment: During the UK football uptick that began in 2006, it was a lack of success against two of the Benchmark Four, Mississippi State (2-4) and South Carolina (1-5), plus Tennessee (1-5, three last-second defeats) that kept Kentucky from a major positive breakthrough.


    2011 record: 7-6 (lost to North Carolina State in the Belk Bowl)

    Record since 2006: 41-34

    Coach: Charlie Strong (14-11 in two years at U of L)

    Record vs. UK since 2006: 2-4

    Record vs. UK in 2000s: 7-5

    Strong vs. UK: 1-1

    Joker Phillips vs. U of L: 1-1

    Comment: Strong's overall record (14-12) is not that much better than Phillips (11-14 in a far tougher league), so it is fascinating that the gap in perception of U of L football (rising) vs. UK football (stagnant to declining) is wider than the Grand Canyon.


    2011 record: 7-6 (beat Wake Forest in Music City Bowl)

    Record since 2006: 37-38 (16-32 SEC)

    Coach: Dan Mullen (21-17 in three years at MSU)

    Record vs. UK since 2006: 4-2

    Record vs. UK in the 2000s: 7-5

    Mullen vs. UK: 3-0

    Joker Phillips vs. MSU: 0-2

    Comment: The failure to beat State in Commonwealth Stadium cost Kentucky eight-win regular seasons in 2007 and 2009 and bowl eligibility in 2011.


    2011 record: 11-2 (beat Nebraska in the Capital One Bowl)

    Record since 2006: 48-30 (24-24 SEC)

    Coach: Steve Spurrier (55-35 in seven years at USC; 197-75-2 in 22 years a college head coach)

    Record vs. UK since 2006: 5-1

    Record vs. UK in the 2000s: 11-1

    Spurrier vs. UK: 18-1 (12-0 at Florida; 6-1 at South Carolina)

    Joker Phillips vs. USC: 1-1

    Comment: From 2006-09, UK and USC were almost identical: Kentucky went 30-22 overall, 12-20 in the SEC; Carolina went 28-23, 13-19. But fueled by the successful recruitment of in-state stars such as Alshon Jeffrey, Marcus Lattimore and Jadeveon Clowney, Spurrier is 20-7 (11-5 SEC) in the past two years while Kentucky has fallen back (11-14, 4-12).


    2011 record: 6-7 (lost to Cincinnati in Liberty Bowl)

    Record since 2006: 26-48 (10-38 SEC)

    Coach: James Franklin (6-7 in one year)

    Record vs. UK since 2006: 2-4

    Record vs. UK in 2000s: 4-8

    Franklin vs. UK: 1-0

    Joker Phillips vs. Vandy: 1-1

    Comment: Franklin signed three four-star recruits in his 2012 class (Rivals) and has three more such commitments to date for 2013.

For all the negativity that currently engulfs Kentucky Wildcats football, the past six seasons have — by the historically pigskin-challenged standards of UK — been pretty darned OK.

Since 2006, UK has five bowl games, four winning seasons, three upsets of Top 10 foes, two road wins over traditional SEC titans (Auburn and Georgia) and a long-coveted victory over Tennessee.

Yet if you want to know why, in a period of relative Wildcats football strength, Kentucky has yet to break through for the genuinely special season, you need only look at the Cats' performance against the schools I call UK's "Benchmark Four."

To generate sustained football upward mobility at Kentucky, there are four schools that UK plays every year that the Cats have to get the upper hand on:

1.) Louisville, Kentucky's annual intrastate non-conference rival.

2.) Mississippi State. Kentucky's permanent Southeastern Conference cross-divisional opponent (for now) from the West.

3.) South Carolina. The school that, since the SEC split into football divisions in 1992, has historically been one rung above UK in the East.

4.) Vanderbilt. The school that, since the SEC split into football divisions in 1992, has historically been one rung below UK in the East.

For Kentucky football to take a lasting step forward, it has to get to the point where it is going at least 3-1 most years against the Benchmark Four.

So far, UK football has never come close to sustaining that level of success against them.

Since Louisville became a permanent Kentucky football opponent in 1994, UK has won as many as three times in a season against the Benchmark Four only three times (1998, 2002 and 2010). Only once, in '98, when Tim Couch and Craig Yeast led the Wildcats to the Outback Bowl, has Kentucky gone 4-0 in the same season against Louisville, Mississippi State, South Carolina and Vanderbilt.

Want to know why UK's five-year bowl streak ended in 2011?

It was the 0-4 record Kentucky turned in against the Benchmark Four last year.

Want to know why Rich Brooks never got to eight wins in a regular season as UK head coach?

It was the fact that from 2006-09, he never did better than 2-2 against the Benchmark Four.

Want to know why there seems to be an overwhelming pessimism among many Kentucky fans for the 2012 football season?

In part, it is because the entire Benchmark Four enter the year with more positive football momentum than UK.

1.) Louisville. Charlie Strong has 15 starters back from a young team that won five of its final six Big East games (including a road win at West Virginia) to share the league championship in 2011.

2.) Mississippi State. Coach Dan Mullen has 12 starters back from the team that beat Kentucky in Lexington a year ago (SEC expansion produced a scheduling quirk that brings the Bulldogs back to Commonwealth Stadium again this year). UK has yet to solve the puzzle that is Mullen, with the MSU head man currently standing 3-0 against Kentucky.

3.) South Carolina. The laser strong enough to remove the 54-3 beating Steve Spurrier and Carolina tattooed onto Kentucky a year ago may not exist. Spurrier has homebred stars Marcus Lattimore and Jadeveon Clowney back from a team that won 11 games a year ago. The Gamecocks are expected to challenge for the SEC East crown in 2012.

4.) Vanderbilt. James Franklin led the Commodores to the Liberty Bowl as a rookie head coach in 2011 and has 15 starters returning from the team that humiliated Kentucky 38-8 at Nashville. Franklin also adds a ballyhooed (by Vandy standards) incoming recruiting class.

Bottom line: If the games were to be played this Saturday, all of the Benchmark Four teams would be favored to beat Kentucky.

For Phillips to have the type of season that removes the heat beneath his coaching seat, it almost certainly will require at least two wins against the Benchmark Four.

From the long view, SEC newcomer Missouri may become another UK football bench mark.

Of the original Benchmark Four, Kentucky has a winning record against only one (Vanderbilt) in the 2000s. Even since 2006, UK is only 11-13 combined against U of L,MSU, USC and Vandy.

For Kentucky to ever climb the football ladder and stay there, it has to do better against the Benchmark Four.

How Kentucky coaches have fared against the Benchmark Four
Coach (Years)U of LMiss. StS.C.VandyTotal
Bill Curry (1990-96)1-23-43-22-59-13
Hal Mumme (1997-2000)2-21-32-23-18-8
Guy Morriss (2001-02)1-11-10-22-04-4
Rich Brooks (2003-09)3-44-30-75-212-16
Joker Phillips (2010-present)1-10-21-11-13-5

Mark Story: (859) 231-3230.Email: Twitter: @markcstory.Blog:

Lexington Herald-Leader is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service