'Promised Land': Engaging but lopsided

'Promised Land' tackles controversy over fracking, but the fight, while engaging, isn't fair

McClatchy-Tribune News ServiceJanuary 3, 2013 


    'Promised Land'


    R for language. Focus Features. 1:46. Fayette Mall, Hamburg, Nicholasville.

Promised Land is an engaging and entertaining — if preachy — look at Big Energy and fracking — the land-and-water-wrecking practice of drilling and pumping water and chemicals into the ground to extract natural gas from shale.

To Steve Butler (Matt Damon), a "consultant" who's from farm country himself, farming and the small farm town lifestyle are "delusional self- mythology." His "money for nothing" offer — underground leases — is "the only way (embattled, indebted small farm owners) have to get back."

He's just received a big promotion with Global Cross Power Solutions. But dropping into an Anytown, U.S.A., named McKinley, with his partner, Sue (Frances McDormand), is a sobering come-down. It might be a one-bar/one-gas-station town, but the locals are going to make him work for this.

Hal Holbrook is the high school science teacher who has Googled "fracking." And as willfully uninformed as some of his shortsighted, let's-cash-in neighbors might be, the teacher gets things called to a vote. Bribes to the local board of supervisors won't be enough.

To make matters worse, a slick "hippy environmentalist" (John Krasinski) shows up with posters of dead cows and poisoned farms. You almost start to feel sorry for the fracking folks as public opinion shifts.

Damon and Krasinski co-wrote the script, and they set up a war of wills — rivals trash-talking each other, both flirting with the cute age-appropriate schoolmarm (Rosemarie DeWitt). Who will win?

But we already know that, don't we? The movie is a stacked deck of cards. Back when they filmed Other People's Money, the idea was to surprise the audience by making the populist side and the Big Business side of an argument compelling, ration al and reasonable. Not here.

McKinley — the movie was filmed near Pittsburgh — really is dying. We see desperation in the eyes of the first farmer we meet (Tim Guinee of TV's Revolution). Others, such as a rube played by Lucas Black, just envision dollar signs. But in either case, their way of living is going extinct. Promised Land pulls its punches in making that counter-argument.

Damon, an Oscar-winning writer, does something nobody else in Hollywood would do: write a dumb character for himself to play. Steve is blindsided by the science teacher, humiliated and silenced in a way no sharp salesman would be. He's been working in this business for years and never let himself see the consequences of his actions?

Krasinski and Damon make well-matched romantic and moral rivals. McDormand's Sue is the flinty, no- nonsense sell-out who refuses to learn what Steve is finding out. DeWitt's performance is limited to flashing her smile and biting her lip as she flirts. Director Gus Van Sant, a Louisville native, captures bucolic nature, lands the jokes and does well by the many friendly and unfriendly bar scenes.

But an evenly matched fight makes for more convincing conflict and better drama. And we needed to see a lot more conflict within Damon's character. You can't play "dumb" and "morally compromised" when you can't say "I'm a good guy" like you don't quite believe it.

Lexington Herald-Leader is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service