Words' ancient history

Published: May 15, 2013 

When researchers from England's University of Reading recently announced they had discovered 23 "ultraconserved" words - words, that is, which appear to have come down from an ancestral language 15,000 years old - I couldn't help thinking of John D'Agata and his 2010 book "About a Mountain."

There, D'Agata writes of the difficulty in establishing an adequate warning system for Nevada's Yucca Mountain, where nuclear waste will be stored (theoretically, anyway) for 10,000 years. Who knows, he wonders, what language then will sound like? Will there be any common markers, any way to talk to each other over such a span of time?

Language, after all, is in a constant state of evolution: Words and usage change, dialects go extinct. In a landscape this conditional, D'Agata argues, the only thing we know is that we know nothing; past and future are a void across which communication is fleeting when it is possible at all.

The Reading findings point to another conclusion, which is that certain core words, core concepts, have always been with us, that they are the building blocks of not just language but also society. In that sense, the 23 words are instructive, both for how simple they are and also how resonant: blunt, unadorned words, concrete, descriptive but able to encompass more abstract relationships as well.

Here is the list: thou, I, not, that, we, to give, who, this, what, man/male, ye, old, mother, to hear, hand, fire, to pull, black, to flow, bark, ashes, to spit, worm. What's interesting is that so many of these words have to do with direct engagement - I, thou, we, ye - the language of a back-and-forth. This suggests that, even 15,000 years ago, we were already using language for negotiation, as a way to bridge the differences between us, to think about (and build?) community.

Some words seem obvious and elemental: fire, hand, give, mother, man. Others are more surprising on the surface. "Spit" is one of those great words that can express an action or an emotion; we spit to get rid of a bitter taste. And "worm," which is in actuality the most universal - it is the common fate of every one of us to be eaten by the creatures it represents.

I don't know whether that's what our linguistic ancestors had in mind, but looking at this list, I feel a kind of kinship, at the level of our shared humanity. 15,000 years is a long time - far longer than both the 10,000-year communication gap at Yucca Mountain and also what was previously thought to be the lifespan of a language (9,000 years or so) - but not long enough, apparently, to sever us from the core connection, the words that give shape to who we are.

Order Reprint Back to Top

Top Jobs

View All

Find a Home

Find a Car

Search New Cars
Ads by Yahoo!