Armistead Maupin's tales come to a fine and fitting end

Los Angeles TimesFebruary 6, 2014 

  • BOOK REVIEW

    'The Days of Anna Madrigal'

    By Armistead Maupin

    Harper. 368 pp. $26.99.

The first time Armistead Maupin ended his Tales of the City serial — in 1989, with his sixth novel, Sure of You — he did it with a departure. Mary Ann Singleton, who had initiated the series by calling her mother in Cleveland to say she was staying in San Francisco, took a network TV job and left the Bay Area for New York.

It was a sad if not unexpected outcome. In the 15 years since Maupin had started writing about Mary Ann, her friends Michael, Mona, Brian and their irrepressible landlady, Anna Madrigal, a lot had happened: Anita Bryant, the People's Temple, AIDS. Maupin was ready to move on. It was nearly two decades before he returned to these characters, first with the 2007 novel Michael Tolliver Lives and then with the follow-up, Mary Ann in Autumn, in 2010.

What makes Tales of the City so resonant is Maupin's ability to draw broad, human lessons from the particularity of his characters' lives. This is why it has struck such a chord for close to 40 years: adapted into three miniseries and an opera, the source of Tales-related tours of San Francisco.

Now, Maupin has chosen to end the series again with The Days of Anna Madrigal, a work that is less about departure than coming home. Featuring the full complement of Tales regulars (with the exception of Mona, who died in 1984's Babycakes), the book is an elegy — for San Francisco, for its characters, for a way of life.

"Her days were full of such small surrenders," Maupin writes of Mrs. Madrigal, now 93 and marginally mobile, "so why make a fuss over them? You could see them as loss, or you could see them as simplification. His daughter Mona would have called this an act of faith, this Zen letting-go of familiar pleasures. Anna chose to think of it as leaving like a lady."

That sense of mortality is in the atmosphere of The Days of Anna Madrigal, a novel about coming to terms. It follows the standard Tales formula of shifting from character to character, although it is not, for the most part, a formulaic book. Rather, Maupin is interested here in aging, in contraction, in what happens as things shut down.

It's true not only of Mrs. Madrigal but also of Michael, who at 62 has enjoyed an extended second act thanks to an AIDS drug cocktail, and Mary Ann, on the other side of cancer surgery.

"Sixty-two was a lot like twelve and hormonal," Michael reflects. "Teenagers rage against the end of childhood, old people against the end of everything. Instability was a permanent condition that adapted with the times."

We see ourselves in Michael, a gay man who found love when he least expected; his husband, Ben, 22 years younger, is one of the series' most compelling second-generation characters. We see ourselves in Mary Ann, who remains the prodigal, unsure of whether, or to what extent, she has been welcomed back.

Then, of course, there's Mrs. Madrigal, den mother for this tribe of lost souls, who from the living room of her fictional apartment house at 28 Barbary Lane held together their community. Now living in a different apartment, she continues to exert an influence, although she has to settle a few last matters of her own.

Such a settling becomes part of the narrative of The Days of Anna Madrigal, as if Maupin couldn't end the series without giving us the full story of the woman at its center all along. This is a tricky decision, since we know so much about her already — that she is transsexual, raised in a house of prostitution, someone who has transformed herself in every imaginable way.

Although he has never shifted time frames in his fiction, Maupin interweaves chapters that detail the character's early life in Nevada, and what she had to overcome. This takes a little while to get going; the first flashback chapters seem slightly out of place. So too a late chapter in which Maupin reveals the essential sin with which Mrs. Madrigal has to reckon, a moment that blurs into melodrama.

And yet melodrama is Maupin's stock-in-trade, the essence of an ongoing social novel that began as a daily newspaper serial, with a cliffhanger every 900 words. It's what he does with it that's important, and in The Days of Anna Madrigal, he is as moving as he has ever been.

Lexington Herald-Leader is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service