'Lincoln's Boys' examines how his 2 personal secretaries shaped presidential legacy

Los Angeles TimesFebruary 16, 2014 

  • BOOK REVIEW

    'Lincoln's Boys: John Hay, John Nicolay, and the War for Lincoln's Image'

    By Joshua Zeitz

    Viking. 400 pp. $29.95.

Sometimes political careers are born of chance.

John Nicolay and John Hay were young men working in Springfield, Ill., when they became involved with the political life of Abraham Lincoln before his 1860 U.S. presidential campaign. Tireless and smart, the friends proved themselves indispensable to Lincoln, who brought them with him to the White House as his personal secretaries — in effect, the president's gatekeepers.

In his new book, Lincoln's Boys: John Hay, John Nicolay, and the War for Lincoln's Image, author Joshua Zeitz skillfully recounts what were heady days for Nicolay and Hay, even as they were tragic days for the nation. The friends lived in the White House and wielded considerable power as advisers and conduits of Lincoln's orders. During the four years of the Lincoln presidency, they had as good a view of the unfolding Civil War battles — military and political — as Lincoln himself.

And after the assassination, the friends tasked themselves with chronicling Lincoln's life, leading to publication of the 10- volume Lincoln: A History. The series and related Abraham Lincoln: Complete Works, co-edited by the two men, remain part of the foundation for how modern Americans view the nation's 16th president. Or, as Zeitz phrases it, the creation of the "Lincoln Memorial Lincoln."

Zeitz builds his book on known sources and known histories but turns the glass a bit to give us a different view of an already deeply mined era. So this isn't a book of revelations but a series of interconnected stories about friendship, political and economic forces that made war over the morality of slavery, and about the transformation of personal experience and written records into definitive history.

Those were remarkable days involving remarkable people, and Zeitz does an admirable job bringing them to life, from the boredom Hay felt in returning to Illinois after the excitement of studying at Brown University in Providence, R.I., to the swirl of activity in the Lincoln White House as the war unfolded to the aftermath of Lincoln's assassination.

The "boys" were rewarded for their work and loyalty. Each was given a diplomatic post in Lincoln's second term — both in Paris — but Lincoln was killed before they left the United States; Hay, in fact, was at Lincoln's bedside when he died. Andrew Johnson, Lincoln's successor, honored the appointments, and the friends headed for Europe before returning in 1889.

The Nicolay-Hay story begins to feel a bit unbalanced after the assassination, but then, that accurately reflects the history. Nicolay was the powerful editor of an Illinois newspaper when he met Lincoln. Hay was trying half-heartedly to build a legal career in his uncle's Springfield office, next to the one occupied by Lincoln. After the assassination, Nicolay resumed his career as editor of the Chicago Republican before returning to Washington as marshal of the U.S. Supreme Court and teaming with Hay for the Lincoln biography.

Where Nicolay did well in his post-Lincoln career, Hay soared, in no small part because of his marriage to Clara Stone, daughter of millionaire Cleveland businessman Amasa Stone. Hay's wealth, and his Lincoln connection, kept him in the top echelon of late 19th- century Republican politics.

It also positioned him for a unique role in U.S. history. Of the four American presidents assassinated in office, Hay was a close friend and adviser to the first three, Lincoln, James Garfield and William McKinley, who appointed Hay secretary of state.

Hay's wealth also began to inform his worldview as he turned more conservative and reflective of the upper class. That began to affect the friendship, which is the main narrative string of the book. Late in life, Hay and Nicolay continued to vacation together, but as Zeitz writes, "more and more it was history that formed their bond, rather than a commonality of lifestyles or interests."

Zeitz also offers interesting analyses of the rise of "Lincolnia," the quest for souvenirs of a man who was not universally admired while he was alive, and of historical revisionism, the pendulum swings of how we perceive the past. He reviews how historians have framed the Civil War and Lincoln as the nation evolved through Reconstruction to the Jim Crow era, then the Great Depression and the civil rights era. Along the way the historical prism shifted — the war was about slavery; no, it was about states' rights; no, it was about agrarian versus industrial economies; etc.

"From these debates has emerged a nuanced and now predominant historical portrait of a masterful politician who evolved personally over the years in his capacity to envision a biracial democracy," Zeitz writes, "and who used his mastery of politics to build and then use popular opinion against an institution that he had always despised on a gut level."

And, Zeitz writes, given Nicolay and Hay's catbird seat as it all unfolded, it stands to reason that the history of Lincoln they wrote more than a century ago remains a key source for historians. Now that's a legacy.

Scott Martelle is the author of The Admiral and the Ambassador: One Man's Obsessive Search for the Body of John Paul Jones, due out in May.

Lexington Herald-Leader is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service