John Rosemond: Big changes might cause toddler's hair pulling

Syndicated ColumnistJuly 22, 2014 Updated 14 hours ago

John Rosemond, nationally syndicated advice columnist

Question: Since our daughter, now 2, was born, we had lived with my parents. As the only grandchild, she was the center of attention. Several months ago, our son was born, and we moved into our own home. Almost immediately, our daughter began pulling her hair out, sometimes in handfuls. Doctors have said she does it for attention, and we should ignore it. That's what we've done, but it has not stopped. It has gotten so bad that I've cut her hair because the side she pulls has gotten so short. I don't know what to do. Any advice would be appreciated.

Answer: The idea that a toddler pulls her hair out by the handfuls as a means of seeking attention is unverifiable. It's the sort of thing professionals say when they have no explanation but can't admit it. Under those circumstances, "she's doing it (whatever it might be) for attention" becomes a default explanation. As such, it's meaningless and unhelpful, because it implies that something is wrong in the child's life; that her parents are failing to meet some crucial psychological need. The result is a lot of parental guilt and anxiety, neither of which are conducive to solving problems involving child behavior of any sort.

Then we come to "just ignore it." That's a default recommendation — again, the sort of thing professionals advise when they're at a loss for advice. The fact is that misbehavior of any sort is difficult to ignore. It's harder still to ignore a child who is causing herself harm. Then, when attempts to ignore don't work, the parents are likely to begin exaggerating the psychological significance of the problem. The result is more guilt and more anxiety.

The simple explanation for your daughter's hair-pulling is "children do odd things, and odd things are more likely when lots of change is taking place in a child's life." In short order, you changed homes and a second child was born. That's a lot of change. Maybe there's a relationship between all that change and your daughter's hair-pulling. Maybe there isn't. Who knows? Furthermore, why does one need to know?

I've had a reasonable amount of success curing hair-pulling in older kids, but toddlers are a different ballgame. The problem is that like nail-biting, hair-pulling can quickly become a habit. So the trick is to do whatever needs to be done to prevent the habit from developing or, if it already has developed, reverse its course.

You said you don't know what to do, but you've already done it: You've cut her hair. Cut it so short she has nothing to grab and yank. If people are so bold as to ask why her hair's so short, tell them out of her earshot. You probably are going to have to keep it short for at least a year, until she begins developing interests that keep her hands busy in more constructive ways. Until then, buy her some cute hats.

Family psychologist John Rosemond answers parents' questions on his website, Rosemond.com.

McClatchy-Tribune Information Services

Lexington Herald-Leader is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service