When Tim Burton’s 2010 live-action version of Alice in Wonderland raked in a billion dollars, there was no question that Disney would pounce on a sequel. Lewis Carroll did write a second book about Alice and her adventures in Wonderland, Through the Looking-Glass, but it proves to be only a suggestion for the film, which arrives this weekend, to a diminished return. It feels reverse-engineered to fit a release date, with a story that feels largely unimaginative and low-stakes.
These films portray Alice as a young lady, played by Mia Wasikowska. The real-world framing device places Alice in a business quandary with the Ascot family. She’s been off captaining ships in China but finds herself, her house and her ship subject to their business whims, and they expect her to conform to a more appropriate career for a lady. So she escapes through a mirror to the magical alternate universe, where her friends the Mad Hatter (Johnny Depp) and the White Queen (Anne Hathaway) share a wary co-existence with the Red Queen (Helena Bonham Carter).
Writer Linda Woolverton and director James Bobin have cooked up a problem for Alice to solve there, although it relegates many characters to the background. Hatter, who thought his family dead, has reason to think they might still be alive, and the realization has thrown him into a depression. To save her friend, Alice goes back in time via a time-travel orb that she steals from Time himself (Sacha Baron Cohen).
It’s a weak premise and weak execution, especially because the stakes go from too low (cheering up her friend) to too high (if she keeps the time-travel orb out too long, time will stop and the universe will end). It’s never convincing why Alice, knowing the risks, would continue to use the orb.
In the first film, Depp’s take on the Mad Hatter became a cultural phenomenon, a fact that becomes curiouser and curiouser when you realize that Depp is essentially doing a clownish drag performance of Carter — who is already doing something like drag herself (the Red Queen’s eye makeup has shades of Divine from Pink Flamingos). On top of that, Cohen’s performance is just a Christoph Waltz impression stuffed inside one of Lady Gaga’s rejected costumes, and the less said about Hathaway’s distracting hand acting, the better.
The premise is so thin that it wears out its welcome before the first act is up. The art direction and design are uninspiring. Time, as one might imagine, lives inside a giant clock, But it’s dour and dark, and the days that Alice visits are set in rooms and houses and streets that don’t offer any glimpses of the nonsense world that makes the stories so unique. But the real problem is that there isn’t enough whimsy in the world to save this unengaging story.
‘Alice Through the Looking Glass’
Rated PG for fantasy action/peril and some language. 1:43. 2D only: Winchester. 2D and 3D: Fayette Mall, Frankfort, Georgetown, Hamburg, Nicholasville, Richmond, Woodhill.