Two-thirds of Appalachia’s coal-industry jobs have disappeared since the 1990s. Now the region is hoping that tourism will help rebuild its economy by tapping into history and its rugged natural beauty.
A Shawnee, Ohio, event re-enacted a Prohibition rally outside a real-life former speakeasy. In Kentucky, they’re constructing an elk-viewing area on a former mountaintop mine near Corbin. Virginia’s Crooked Road traces country music history. Ohio’s Winding Road takes visitors back to the birth of the U.S. labor movement.
“We’d like to promote Appalachia as an exotic, interesting place, not the godforsaken place that we usually get in the national press,” said Todd Christensen, executive director of the Southwest Virginia Cultural Heritage Foundation.
For Ohio activist John Winnenberg, the rebirth goes deeper. As eastern Ohio has endured boom-and-bust cycles — of timber, coal, clay and, lately, oil and gas extraction — residents have internalized a sense of futility and abandonment that’s hard to shake, he said. That mentality could fade if locals succeed in building their own tourism-based economy. “We’ve been owned before,” said Winnenberg, director of The Winding Road initiative, centered in historic Shawnee. “We don’t want to be owned again.”
The promise of a new future for coal country isn’t new. Billions of dollars have been spent closing, reclaiming, reforesting and redeveloping abandoned mine land since the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act passed 40 years ago.
What’s fresh is the new energy among baby boomers and millennials alike, who seem to enjoy the Rust Belt chic of enjoying a drink or an overnight stay in a place full of authentic stories built on sweat and strife.
In Nelsonville, Ohio, Sunday Creek Coal Co. was among dozens of companies that thrived in eastern Ohio during mining’s heyday, 1850 to 1940. Vestiges of that era — opera houses, speakeasies, union halls, railroad depots — are being preserved and promoted for tours, lodging and quirky events, including the re-enactment of a Prohibition rally.
“It’s not creating tourism just for other people. We’re going for ourselves as well,” Winnenberg said.
The Corbin-based Appalachian Wildlife Foundation is developing an ecology education site on Kentucky’s first mountaintop-removal coal mine.
“Capitalizing on the wildlife of the region for conservation, based on our work, turned into a tourist attraction,” board chairman Frank Allen said.
A wildlife center rich with elk, deer, bear and more than 260 species of birds will open in 2019 as mining operations continue nearby. An economic-impact study predicts that the 19-square-mile tract of former mine land will attract 638,000 annual visitors, generate $124 million in annual spending by its fifth year, and create 2,300 jobs.
“The mining has created phenomenal elk habitat. Elk are, by nature, prairie animals, and the grassland habitat that’s created when the coal mines are restored is very conducive to the elk,” Allen said. “It’s kind of the ultimate irony: The ‘evil’ mountaintop removal process and, all of the sudden, it’s created the ideal habitat for wildlife.”
The Monday Creek Restoration Project in New Straitsville, Ohio, gave locals their first look in generations at a clear-running stream, according to project manager Nate Schlater.
“The stream where a lot of my work has been focused, Monday Creek, was a dead stream, declared possibly unrecoverable in 1994,” he said. “Today, there’s 36 species of fish living in the stream. It’s nearing achieving EPA warm-water habitat status. People are now fishing in the stream. My grandkids are catching fish where there’s never been a fish in my lifetime.”
CHANGING ECONOMIES AND MINDS
Coal country overwhelmingly supported President Donald Trump, who pledged to reverse coal’s decline, but just 1,200 new mining jobs have been created across the region since January. That can’t make up for the hemorrhage of the past: In Southwest Virginia, mining employment plunged 45 percent from 1990 to 2014.
Even those with good coal jobs sometimes think they need backup plans. Rodney Embrey said he loves his job in communications at the Buckhingham mine in Corning, Ohio, but he has started a lucrative side business with a friend, selling antiques. Their store is in a building once scheduled for demolition. “It was a dry-goods store when it opened up” in 1905 — an era he and others call “the boom.”
The new economy appears to be attracting jobs, tourists and even new residents to the Virginia region that’s furthest along in its efforts. One study there found that arts, entertainment, recreation and related fields added more than 5,000 jobs between 2000 and 2014. The region’s professional, scientific, education and health sectors also grew by double-digit percentages in 15 years, the study found, as millennials in tech and other location-flexible industries select the region for its downhome charm and outdoor recreation.
“We’ve lost many, many more jobs to coal losses than we’ve attracted,” Christensen said. “But what we’re also finding is that communities that have embraced the creative economy have seen an influx of 25- to 34-year-old college-educated people moving in. We can’t say it’s related, but there’s a correlation.”
He said visitors often come in with a “stereotype of what they think they’ll find. … Nine times out of 10, they leave with a different perspective than what they brought.”