Ivan Reitman — whose directing career includes Ghostbusters and who has a son, Jason, directing Oscar-worthy comedies — has his best outing in decades with No Strings Attached, an amusing flip of the "friends with benefits" sex-leads-to-love romantic-comedy formula.
The movie benefits from another sparkling, sexy and emotionally available performance by Natalie Portman, some clever situations and witty banter that isn't shy about crossing over into Hangover-level raunch.
Elizabeth Meriwether's script has that (500) Days of Summer gimmick, telling the story of this couple in clumps over 15 years. Super-smart Emma met hunky-needy Adam at summer camp, way back when, and they had a momentary fling. Ten years later, they meet again and pretty, flirty Emma (Portman) invites Adam to "this thing" she has to go to. It's her dad's funeral. But dopey-handsome Adam (Ashton Kutcher, not cast against type) doesn't hear the "She's cut off from her emotions" warning bells, even when she confesses, "If you're lucky, you're never going to see me again."
Another chance encounter years later leads to an exchange of phone numbers.
And then, that magical night when the boy drunk-dials the girl and something begins. But don't call it a thoroughly modern romance. Emma, now an MIT-trained doctor, won't have that. She's busy. She's guarded. And she's interested in sex — somebody "in my bed at 2 a.m." — and nothing more.
They have their romps, but snuggling and the like — real intimacy — scares her off. So for Adam, the chase is on.
Portman, almost certainly an Oscar nominee for Black Swan, carries this movie with her warmth and her wicked way with an incredibly crude come-on. Kutcher is better at bringing the funny than in carrying the emotional weight. Reitman didn't suddenly evolve into a warmer, deeper filmmaker, either.
But the director surrounds his leads with funny people saying witty things. Adam's best friend (Jake M. Johnson) mocks him for giving his lady love a gift of balloons — "Who do you think you are, the old guy from Up?" Kevin Kline plays Adam's has-been TV-star dad, a lecher who thinks nothing of taking up with one of Adam's ex-girlfriends. Lake Bell is a leggy but awkward and lovestruck co-worker at Adam's job. (He's a production assistant on a Glee-like high school musical show.)
And wonderful Greta Gerwig (Greenberg) spices up the role of Emma's college pal, the one who barely outgrows that sorority girl's mating call — "I'm so druuuuuunk."
Whatever corners that the writer, Meriwether, paints herself into — and this movie seems stitched from several recent romances, including Rachel Getting Married — cute situations and cheeky dialogue bail her out. You know it's love when the guy makes you a menstruation mix tape: Red Red Wine, I've Got the World on a String and an even more obvious Leona Lewis hit.
And the sentiment — her love of convenience, his love of love — hasn't grown old, through (500) Days of Summer, Up in the Air (by Reitman's son) and Love & Other Drugs, although it might by the time the movie Friends With Benefits hits theaters this summer.