While federal investigators try to track down Kentuckians who go out of state to secure prescription pain pills to sell or abuse, many Kentucky doctors are wrestling with questions of how and when to treat thousands of legitimate patients who need those same drugs.
It's all part of perhaps the hottest national debate in medicine today.
Premium content for only $0.99
For the most comprehensive local coverage, subscribe today.
The discussion revolves around two camps. One holds that pain essentially is an illness in its own right that should be treated aggressively, up to and including the use of powerful narcotic drugs. The other side contends that doctors must be much more conservative, offering narcotics only when they're absolutely sure patients actually need the potentially addicting drugs and are not seeking them to abuse them.
Some nationally known experts, like Dr. Russell Portenoy, a New York pain specialist, say the debate has left many doctors reluctant to prescribe narcotics because they fear being investigated by authorities and many patients reluctant to seek help because they fear being seen as ”pill users.“
”The drugs are highly stigmatized,“ Portenoy said in an interview. ”Doctors who prescribe them are stigmatized by their colleagues; patients who use them are stigmatized by their families, their friends and by other doctors.“
The debate is followed closely by many physicians in Kentucky, where prescription drug abuse is a perennial problem and where several doctors have gone to jail in recent years for running highly profitable ”pill mills“ that cranked out prescriptions to those who abused or sold them.
Authorities say recent enforcement efforts have cut down on such problems in Kentucky, but also have prompted lawbreakers to seek new, out-of-state drug sources. Drug enforcement officers in Eastern and southeastern Kentucky are continuing investigations into traffickers who travel as far as Pennsylvania, Florida and Michigan for prescription narcotics they sell back home.
The pain pill issue surfaced again last month after the Kentucky Board of Medical Licensure suspended Dr. James Heaphy and Dr. Charles Grigsby, both of Lexington, for allegedly overprescribing controlled drugs.
The board said the case against Heaphy, whose license to practice medicine was suspended, includes questions about medical records that appeared to have been falsified or altered.
Grigsby can still practice medicine, but is prohibited from prescribing controlled drugs.
Both Grigsby and Heaphy have hired attorneys and say they will fight to be reinstated.
Some critics contend that such medical board actions have left many Kentucky doctors leery of prescribing narcotics for patients who really need them.
Dr. Preston Nunnelley, the medical board's president, says he's aware that some physicians are fearful, and that he's heard from some of them. But he maintains that doctors who prescribe narcotics for pain have nothing to fear from the board as long as they stick to the rules.
The board upgraded its prescription guidelines in 2003 ”so that physicians could prescribe without fear,“ he said. ”All we're asking is that they follow the guidelines.“
Millions in pain
Just about everybody involved agrees that pain is a serious national health problem.
It is estimated that between 40 million and 80 million Americans suffer from chronic pain — defined as pain that lingers for six months or more — and that many are at least partially disabled as a result. By some estimates, the problem costs America $100 billion a year in medical costs and lost productivity.
Nevertheless, experts such as Dr. Barry Cole, executive director of the American Society of Pain Educators, say millions of sufferers don't get proper relief. The reasons, Cole says, include lack of health insurance, which hinders patients in getting treatment, and doctors who are either afraid to prescribe the necessary drugs or who lack the training to dispense them properly.
”Basically, about every sixth American suffers from pain every day,“ Cole said in an interview. ”If this were cancer, if this were heart disease, if this were HIV, it would be considered the No. 1 health concern in the country. That's the insanity of all this.“
Dr. William O. Witt, chairman emeritus of anesthesiology at the University of Kentucky, says physicians agree that it is proper to prescribe powerful narcotic drugs to treat patients with acute post-surgical pain or pain from illnesses such as cancer.
The debate, Witt said, is about using those drugs to treat patients suffering from chronic, ongoing pain that can stem from many sources, some that are not easily diagnosed.
Witt says he doesn't fault doctors who prescribe narcotics for chronic pain, but he doesn't prescribe them himself because scientific evidence is lacking.
”There are virtually no studies that show improved function and pain relief from these drugs beyond six months,“ he said. ”We're also starting to recognize that when you give these drugs at high dosages over a long period, they actually start to produce pain.“
Witt also contends that the risk of addiction can be high — ”There's a reason these drugs are controlled,“ he said — and that other, non-narcotic approaches are available to help patients with severe long-term pain.
”Here at the university we don't use opioids (narcotics) for chronic pain at all, and we treat lots of pain patients very effectively,“ Witt said.
Alternative methods include non-narcotic drugs, physical exercise and electrical impulse devices to ease pain, he said.
Pain and primary care
On the other side of the argument are doctors such as Russell Portenoy, chairman of pain medicine and palliative care at Beth Israel Medical Center in New York, who think narcotics can be safely and effectively prescribed for chronic pain. Portenoy agrees, however, that supporting scientific evidence still is lacking in many areas.
”Having said that ... it's now the consensus in the pain specialty community that opioids are appropriate for a carefully selected subpopulation of chronic pain patients who can benefit with tolerable side effects and with no problems of abuse,“ Portenoy said.
Identifying those patients, however, isn't easy. For one thing, most patients with chronic pain end up seeking help from primary care physicians because there are only about 10,000 to 12,000 pain specialists to serve the entire country.
Barbara Hunter, a Lexington attorney who represents people with disabilities, also points out that patients who lack health insurance often can't get in to see pain management specialists.
But primary care doctors might lack the time — and the training — to adequately evaluate patients seeking help with chronic pain
Add in the possibility that some of those patients might be faking to get drugs for abuse or resale, and the risk of doctors being duped is high.
In one case reported in Florida earlier this year, a pain doctor who is meticulous about screening patients was fooled by an 80-year-old woman who sold the drugs to supplement her husband's monthly Social Security check.
Even experienced doctors can be taken in, says Dr. Roger Humphries, chairman of emergency medicine at UK. He says that leaves doctors in a ticklish situation.
”It can be very confusing to sort through who is there for an acute pain condition, who's there for a chronic pain condition and who is there for something that is more of a drug addiction problem,“ Humphries said. ”Very often, we have to give the patient the benefit of the doubt. It's an issue emergency physicians struggle with daily.“
Humphries said he would ”rather be duped by someone seeking narcotics ... than to neglect to give medications to someone who really needs them.“
Nunnelley, the medical board chairman, said he agrees that physicians can be duped. But he says doctors can avoid trouble with the medical board if they follow its prescription guidelines, which require doctors to do such things as perform periodic patient checkups, and have patients sign agreements to follow directions and not seek drugs from multiple doctors.
”I can tell you, speaking as the president of the board, that we're not going after anybody who is in compliance with these guidelines,“ Nunnelley said.
In addition, Nunnelley says the medical board is taking other steps to educate and reassure Kentucky doctors, including meeting with physician groups and urging doctors to call the board if they have questions about prescriptions.
He added that he thinks Kentucky's recent prescription abuse problems are coming under control because of the board's efforts and because of KASPER, the state model computer system that tracks prescriptions.
”I recently had a physician come to see me who said he was nervous about continuing to treat chronic pain patients,“ Nunnelley said. ”I gave him a copy of our guidelines and said, "sign contracts with your patients and we're not going to do anything to you as long as you're doing that.'“