Voters in Lexington have seen the best and worst of American politics over the past few months.
The worst was the U.S. Senate race between 30-year incumbent Sen. Mitch McConnell and his Democratic challenger, Secretary of State Alison Lundergan Grimes.
Their campaign was one TV attack ad after another, funded by huge sums of special-interest money. McConnell and Grimes were both zinged by fact-checkers for lies and half-truths.
The main narrative of this campaign was the phony "war on coal" — the myth that Eastern Kentucky coal-mining jobs, which have been disappearing for three decades because of mechanization and market forces, will be saved if only the industry is allowed to inflict more pollution and environmental damage on this state.
Sign Up and Save
Get six months of free digital access to the Lexington Herald-Leader
The candidates agreed to only one debate, and even then rarely strayed from their talking points. Grimes wouldn't admit she voted for President Barack Obama, her party's nominee, and McConnell wouldn't acknowledge the overwhelming scientific consensus about climate change. It was an absurd spectacle.
The race for Lexington mayor was a much different story. Mayor Jim Gray and his challenger, former Police Chief Anthany Beatty, behaved like gentlemen and, more importantly, campaigned on real issues grounded in fact.
They also appeared together in so many debates and public forums that voters had plenty of opportunities to assess them and their positions.
For the most part, Urban County Council candidates also ran issues-oriented campaigns and behaved responsibly.
Why the contrast between local and national politics? The biggest factor, I think, is that races in Lexington's merged city-council government are non-partisan. That prevents every person and idea from having to be labeled and put at odds.
Since the 1980s, America's two-party system has become increasingly nasty and counterproductive. We have devolved into a culture of winner-take-all politics where big money, ideology and partisan gamesmanship often trump common sense and the common good.
Of course, Lexington government isn't completely free of those influences. But the more voters and elected leaders can keep them at bay, the more progress this city will continue to make.
I think Gray was re-elected by a wide margin because most voters could not fault his performance. His administration has combined progressive leadership with good management and fiscal responsibility. And the mayor is the first one to admit that having a good re-election challenger kept him on his toes.
But the race also showed that Beatty is someone who would bring a lot of skill, experience and wisdom to public service should he seek elected office again.
Lexington lost a lot with the retirement of Vice Mayor Linda Gorton, a talented legislator who has a gift for bringing people to consensus. Fortunately, Gorton will be succeeded by someone with similar skills. Steve Kay, the new vice mayor and only returning at-large council member, is a professional facilitator with a reputation for integrity and fairness. Like Gray, he also is not afraid to tackle tough issues others have avoided.
As for the other council members who won races Tuesday, there are no obvious weak links. Kevin Stinnett moved up from a district to an at-large post, while Richard Moloney and Fred Brown returned to council after previous service.
Jake Gibbs is new to public office, but his background and demeanor could make him a model for a constituent-focused district council member. Another newcomer, Susan Lamb, was formerly the council's clerk. She brings to her new job valuable knowledge of how city government really works.
I hated to see Harry Clarke lose re-election, because the retired University of Kentucky music professor did a great job in his one term. But Amanda Mays Bledsoe has a background in government policy that could make her an able successor.
The same is true for state lawyer Angela Evans, who was elected to the district seat Stinnett left. Jennifer Mossotti, Shevawn Akers and Jennifer Scutchfield are good district council members who deserved re-election.
Urban County Council members come from a variety of backgrounds, experiences, party affiliations and political beliefs. But because Lexington's government is non-partisan, citizens hold them to a higher standard. People expect them to work together, reach consensus and move the city forward.
As in the past, Lexington's mayor and council members have the opportunity to show politicians in Frankfort and Washington how to rise above petty politics and get things done for the greater good.