Lexington Herald Leader Logo

Judge hears arguments in coal case | Lexington Herald Leader

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • All News
    • Business
    • Communities
    • Counties
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Lexington
    • Local
    • Most Wanted
    • Nation/World
    • News Photos
    • News Videos
    • Politics
    • Searchable Databases
    • State
    • Watchdog
    • Columns
    • Tom Eblen
    • All Sports
    • UK Sports
    • College Sports
    • Next Cats Recruiting
    • High School
    • Horses
    • Kentucky Speedway
    • Lexington Legends
    • Reds
    • MLB
    • NBA
    • NASCAR
    • NFL
    • Sports Photos
    • Sports Videos
    • Columns
    • John Clay's Columns
    • Mark Story
    • Next Cats Recruiting
    • All UK Sports
    • Next Cats Recruiting
    • Baseball
    • Basketball - Men
    • Basketball - Women
    • Recruiting
    • Ex-Cats
    • Football
    • UK Photos
    • UK Videos
    • More UK Sports
    • Columns
    • John Clay's Blog
    • Mark Story
    • Politics
    • Elections
    • All Entertainment
    • Books
    • Celebrities
    • Comics
    • Puzzles & Games
    • Events Calendar
    • Horoscopes
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Restaurants
    • Stage & Dance
    • TV
    • Visual Arts
    • Entertainment Photos
    • Entertainment Videos
    • News Blogs
    • Kentucky Weather
    • Photo Archive
    • Sports Blogs
    • John Clay's Blog
    • High School
    • UK Football
    • UK Men's Basketball
    • UK Women's Basketball
    • Lexington Legends
    • Entertainment Blogs
    • Walter Tunis on Music
    • All Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Joel Pett
    • Letters to the Editor
    • National Columnists
    • Op-Ed
    • Submit a Letter
    • All Living
    • Celebrations
    • Family
    • Fashion
    • Food & Drink
    • Fru-Gal: Deb Morris
    • Health & Medicine
    • Home & Garden
    • Paul Prather
    • Religion
    • Travel
    • Readers' Choice
    • Kentucky Obituaries
    • Obituaries in the News
    • Submit an Obituary
    • Customer Service
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • E-edition
    • Page Reprints
    • Photo Reprints
    • RSS Feeds
    • Special Sections
    • Site Information
    • Advertise With Us
    • Archives
    • Mobile
    • Mobile Apps & eReaders
    • Newsletters
    • Social
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Google+
    • Today's Circulars
    • Classifieds
    • Jobs
    • Cars
    • Homes
    • Homeseller
    • Legal Notices
  • Place an Ad
  • Mobile & Apps

Kentucky

Judge hears arguments in coal case

By Beth Musgrave - bmusgrave@herald-leader.com

    ORDER REPRINT →

January 28, 2011 12:00 AM

FRANKFORT — A Franklin Circuit Court judge said Thursday that he would rule soon on whether a group of environmentalists could intervene in a $660,000 settlement between the state and two mining companies over lax water pollution reporting.

Judge Phillip Shepherd heard more than two hours of arguments Thursday from environmental groups, the Energy and Environment Cabinet, and ICG and Frasure Creek Mining on whether the environmental groups could intervene in a consent judgment between the state and the mining companies.

Lawyers for the environmental groups, which include North Carolina-based Appalachian Voices, Kentuckians for the Commonwealth, Kentucky Riverkeeper and New York-based Waterkeeper Alliance — have argued that the settlement was overbroad and that the monetary penalties were too low.

Mary Cromer, a lawyer for the Appalachian Citizens Law Center in Whitesburg, told Shepherd that the consent judgment was hammered out between the agency and the mining companies and that there was no transparency into how the decisions were reached regarding problems with lax procedures and violations at third-party water-testing laboratories.

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to the Lexington Herald-Leader

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

"We are acting in the public interest," Cromer said of the environmental groups.

If the state had been acting in the interest of the public, "Why would it oppose our application" to intervene?" Cromer asked.

Lawyers for the cabinet and the mining industry said there is no provision in state regulations to allow a citizen to intervene. The Clean Water Act, however, does allow citizens to intervene. The attorneys argued that the environmental groups should file their complaint in federal court, not state court.

Lawyers for the environmental groups countered that the Energy and Environment Cabinet and the mining companies decided to file the consent judgment in state court. If Shepherd approves the settlement, it might hurt the environmentalists' chances of getting their case in federal court because a state court has said the punishments decided by the state were adequate.

Mary Stephens, a lawyer for the Energy and Environment Cabinet, said the cabinet acted swiftly to address the concerns of the environmentalists when they showed that the third-party labs hired to test pollutants had falsified documents.

"The cabinet has acted quickly and thoroughly," Stephens said.

Lawyers for the mining companies said the state and the mining companies worked out the settlement over the problems found in the water-testing laboratories. If Shepherd allows the environmental groups to intervene in that agreement, it could allow other groups to intervene in other settlements, said Anne Chesnut, a lawyer for Frasure Creek Mining.

"They cannot block a settlement," Chesnut said of the environmental groups. "They can not renegotiate a settlement. ... They are allowed to comment."

Allowing the environmental groups to intervene would reopen the settlement agreement to further litigation, Chesnut said.

It was the environmental groups that alerted the cabinet to potential problems with water testing. In October, the groups notified the state that they were going to sue under the federal Clean Water Act. In a review of discharge monitoring reports submitted to the state by the companies, the groups said there were 20,000 instances of falsified documents or excess pollutants discharged into creeks in Eastern Kentucky.

The notice of intent to sue triggered a review by the state, which found 2,765 violations. The environmentalists argue that the violations could have equaled a fine as large as $103 million. Instead, the two mining companies combined are paying $660,000.

The cabinet and the mining companies have countered that many of the problems with the water monitoring reports were errors and were not intentional. The environmental groups argue that many of those reports were falsified.

Roger Nicholson, senior vice president of International Coal Group, said his organization has switched to different third-party laboratories after the problems were reported.

"The anti-mining groups' claims of fraud are patently false and ludicrous, and we resent their efforts to impugn the character of our employees, who live and work in the communities where we operate," Nicholson said in a written statement.

Stephens said the two third-party labs that were the subject of the legal action are now out of business.

  Comments  

Videos

Coal town’s energy project lands $200,000 donation

Live in this Kentucky county? The sheriff says don’t call his office for help.

View More Video

Trending Stories

Teen brothers killed in accident on Harrodsburg Road

February 17, 2019 10:52 AM

‘It’s a good day to die.’ Man pulls gun on couple wearing MAGA caps at Kentucky Sam’s Club

February 18, 2019 02:29 PM

Even Tennessee’s players agreed: ‘Kentucky was totally kicking our butt.’

February 17, 2019 01:07 AM

Vote for the Kentucky.com Girls’ Basketball Player of the Week (Feb. 10-16, 2019)

February 17, 2019 09:57 PM

‘That’s crazy.’ Herro’s rebounding performance stuns Kentucky teammate.

February 17, 2019 01:57 AM

Read Next

Kentucky

Bull strikes, injures several participants in ‘Cowboy Pinball’ game at Kentucky rodeo.

By Mike Stunson

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 18, 2019 04:53 PM

Several people were butted by a bull during a game of Cowboy Pinball in Owensboro at the Bull Bash event. The goal of the game was to be the last person standing in your circle to win $100.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to the Lexington Herald-Leader

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE KENTUCKY

Kentucky students need border wall before a new middle school, Sen. Lindsey Graham says.

National Politics

Kentucky students need border wall before a new middle school, Sen. Lindsey Graham says.

February 18, 2019 11:41 AM

Kentucky

Driver of submerged semi in Wisconsin ID’d; 2nd body found

February 18, 2019 05:16 PM

Kentucky

Ky. police officer shot during pursuit; 1 suspect arrested

February 18, 2019 05:16 PM

Kentucky

Man accused of pulling gun on couple wearing ‘MAGA’ hats

February 18, 2019 04:31 PM
New owners plan to move historic riverboat to Ohio winery

Business

New owners plan to move historic riverboat to Ohio winery

February 18, 2019 01:43 PM
Teacher brings furry friends to help comfort students

Kentucky

Teacher brings furry friends to help comfort students

February 18, 2019 11:58 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Lexington Herald Leader App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Archives
Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Place a Classified Ad
  • Local Deals
  • Digital Solutions
  • Media Kit
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story