Preakness: McGaughey unfazed but not overjoyed by No. 1 post in starting gate

grooms adjusted the bridle of Kentucky Derby winner Orb after a workout Thursday at Pimlico Race Course in Baltimore. Orb, the even-money favorite in the Preakness Stakes on Saturday, drew the rail position for the race.
grooms adjusted the bridle of Kentucky Derby winner Orb after a workout Thursday at Pimlico Race Course in Baltimore. Orb, the even-money favorite in the Preakness Stakes on Saturday, drew the rail position for the race. Associated Press

BALTIMORE — Pretty much the last post position trainer Shug McGaughey would have wished for Orb heading into Saturday's Preakness Stakes was the inside rail in the nine-horse field.

In what might be the bay colt's first downer in weeks, the No. 1 slot is exactly where the Kentucky Derby winner landed for the start of his quest to secure the second leg of the Triple Crown.

True to his nature, McGaughey didn't flinch even as a smattering of groans cropped up around him.

If what the Hall of Fame trainer has seen continues to hold true, it's going to take more than this to bring Orb back to the field.

Even with the inside post, Phipps Stables and Stuart Janney III's homebred was made the overwhelming even-money favorite over eight others for the 138th running of the Preakness at Pimlico Race Course.

Though no horse has won the Preakness from post No. 1 since Tabasco Cat in 1994, overmatched long shots have typically been fated to that slot recently. Since 1994, the only Preakness starters who landed in the No. 1 post and went off at single-digit odds were Cherokee's Boy (8th in 2003) and Lion Heart (4th in 2004).

The No. 1 post is considered the kiss of death in the Kentucky Derby — forcing the unfortunate animal to angle away from the rail and deal with as many as 19 rivals closing in on them — but there is not such automatic doom associated with the same spot in the smaller Preakness field.

Given Orb's preference to take back off the pace anyhow, his connections were mildly subdued by the news but in no way deterred.

"If I had come out the '1' in the Derby, you'd almost have felt like you needed to go home," McGaughey said. "But I don't feel that way here. It's not nearly (as bad) as it would be for the Derby. In the Derby ... you have to kind of shove your way out of there or you're going to get shut off and I don't think that will be the case here.

"It's a pretty straight start; there are only nine horses. I think we'll just hold our position and see how the race spreads out."

Where jockey Joel Rosario ultimately settles Orb in the 13⁄16-mile test will be determined in part by how the race's expected speedsters respond after the break.

Santa Anita Derby winner Goldencents and his forward-placed ways will be right alongside Orb in post No. 2, Titletown Five, another who has shown early speed, will be in post No. 3.

"We're completely comfortable with No. 2. If all goes well, (Orb) is going to be behind us — at least early," said Goldencents' trainer, Doug O'Neill, who won last year's Preakness with I'll Have Another. "That's where having a cool-headed guy like Kevin (jockey Krigger) will come into play. We have a horse who has gate speed, and we'll just have to see how it works out."

Mylute, fifth in the Kentucky Derby, was made the 5-to-1 second choice out of post No. 5. Illinois Derby winner Departing, the 6-to-1 choice, will break from post No. 4.

"Orb isn't going to go on with it, so he's going to have to go around," said Al Stall Jr., trainer of Departing. "Out of the nine numbers, the '1' is probably the one you want the least."

The last time McGaughey saddled a Preakness starter was 1989, when his champion Easy Goer ended up the beaten favorite after a memorable stretch duel with Kentucky Derby hero Sunday Silence.

McGaughey came into that year's Preakness unsure what Easy Goer would have for his rival, but Orb would need to show some regression off his 21/2-length Kentucky Derby triumph to really level the playing field Saturday.

There was no such evidence during Orb's 4-furlong move at Belmont Park on Monday, when the son of Malibu Moon covered the distance in :47.18 while looking as if he were in a high gallop.

"That's as pretty a work as a Derby horse going into the Preakness can do in my opinion," said Hall of Fame trainer D. Wayne Lukas, who has three Preakness starters in Will Take Charge, Oxbow and Titletown Five. "I have great respect for the way that horse is going to show up."

Since he is the unabashed top target for the rest of the 3-year-old division currently, the No. 1 slot might just prove that much more fitting for Orb come Saturday evening.

"It's a different feeling being here as the Derby winner, but I'm relishing that too," McGaughey said. "I think there is more there with him. I can't wait to run him Saturday afternoon, and I hope we'll see something special."


When: 6:20 p.m. Saturday

TV: NBC-18

Where: Pimlico Race Course in Baltimore

For: 3-year-olds

Distance: 1 3⁄16 miles

Grade: I

Purse: $1 million

Pole position Horse Owner Trainer Jockey Odds

1 Orb Stuart Janney/Phipps Stable Shug McGaughey Joel Rosario Even

2 Goldencents W.C. Racing/Kenney/RAP Doug O'Neill Kevin Krigger 8-1

3 Titletown Five Hornung/Martin et al D. Wayne Lukas Julien Leparoux 30-1

4 Departing Claiborne Farm Al Stall Jr. Brian Hernandez Jr. 6-1

5 Mylute GoldMark/Whisper Hill Farm Tom Amoss Rosie Napravnik 5-1

6 Oxbow Calumet Farm D. Wayne Lukas Gary Stevens 15-1

7 Will Take Charge Willis D. Horton D. Wayne Lukas Mike Smith 12-1

8 Govenor Charlie Michael E. Pegram Bob Baffert Martin Garcia 12-1

9 Itsmyluckyday Trilogy Stable/Laurie Plesa Eddie Plesa Jr. John Velazquez 10-1

Related stories from Lexington Herald Leader