Politics & Government

Kentucky’s main pension fund for state workers was already frail. It just got weaker.

Senate president says public employees must realize pension system is ‘broke’

Senate President Robert Stivers appealed to public employees in February 2018, saying that a GOP pension plan is needed because "the system is broke, and we have to fix it."
Up Next
Senate President Robert Stivers appealed to public employees in February 2018, saying that a GOP pension plan is needed because "the system is broke, and we have to fix it."

As bad as Kentucky’s pension prospects were, it turns out there was still room for further decline.

As of June 30, Kentucky state government’s primary pension fund had only 12.9 percent of the money it’s expected to need to make future payments to tens of thousands of retirees, compared to 13.6 percent a year earlier, according to data presented Thursday to the Kentucky Retirement Systems Board of Trustees.

The pension fund — managed by the KRS board within the Kentucky Employees Retirement System — had about $2 billion in assets and $15.6 billion in liabilities on June 30, actuarial advisers told the trustees for their annual update.

The KERS (Non Hazardous) fund is considered one of the nation’s worst-off public pension funds, largely due to many years of inadequate contributions by state leaders and unreasonable expectations about investment returns and payroll growth.

Starting in Fiscal Year 2017, Gov. Matt Bevin and the legislature committed to fully paying the fund’s annual recommended contributions in the state budget. This has meant diverting hundreds of millions of dollars from other spending items, such as education, social services and infrastructure.

While that full funding has slowed the growth of Kentucky’s pension debt, the advisers said the additional money was offset by a 15 percent spike in retirements in Fiscal Year 2018 — due to controversial changes proposed to the public pension systems — and a steady drop in government employment in Kentucky. KRS contributions are tied to payroll, so fewer public workers is a problem.

It’s possible the funding level for the state pension fund could fall as low as 11 percent next year before rebounding and slowly, over several decades, climbing back up again, said KRS board chairman David Harris, an investment manager who was appointed two years ago by Bevin.

But that depends on future governors and legislatures sticking with the plan for full funding, Harris added. In this fiscal year, he said, the state’s roughly $11 billion General Fund will pay $2.4 billion into the various public pension systems. And that sum will have to rise over time, he said.

“The contributions now coming in are about equal to the benefits going out,” Harris said. “The fact is that funding is critical. ... All of this is caused by the fact that from 2000 to 2015, we didn’t put enough money in. It’s not investment related. It’s funding, funding, funding.”

There are 122,386 people enrolled in KERS (Non-Hazardous). The 36,725 active members still contributing to the fund through their paychecks have an average salary of $41,133, and the 40,762 retired members drawing benefits collect an average annual pension of $21,699. The remainder are considered “inactive” — they’re still employed somewhere, but not in a job covered by KERS.

Overall, KRS is responsible for providing pension and medical benefits for 372,524 active and retired public employees in Kentucky. It’s divided into three separate pension systems: KERS for state government employees, the State Police Retirement System for Kentucky State Police and the County Employees Retirement System for local government employees.

Within KERS and CERS, there are separate pension funds for employees with non-hazardous and hazardous jobs.

On Thursday, actuarial advisers told the KRS board that its combined unfunded liability had grown to $23.6 billion as of June 30, up from $23.14 billion a year earlier.

Among its individual plans, KERS (Hazardous) was funded at 55.5 percent, compared to 54.1 percent last year; CERS (Non-Hazardous) was funded at 52.7 percent, compared to 52.8 percent last year; CERS (Hazardous) was funded at 48.4 percent, compared to 44.8 percent last year; and SPRS was funded at 27.1 percent, compared to 27 percent last year.

School teachers are enrolled at a different agency, the $18 billion Teachers’ Retirement System of Kentucky, which has 125,096 active and retired members.

New financial data for TRS won’t be released until later this month. On the agency’s website, it reported having 56 percent of the assets it will need to meet future obligations as of Fiscal Year 2017. That number drops to 39 percent under a new and stricter set of government accounting rules crafted for poorly funded pension plans, known as “GASB 67.”

Attorney General Andy Beshear celebrates Judge Phillip Shepherd's ruling that the Republican pension law is unconstitutional. Governor Matt Bevin is expected to appeal the ruling.

Kentucky Attorney General Andy Beshear posted this video on Facebook explaining a lawsuit he filed with the Kentucky Education Association and the Fraternal Order of Police to challenge Kentucky's new pension law.

Steve Pitt, general counsel for Kentucky Governor Matt Bevin, spoke after the Kentucky Supreme Court heard arguments Thursday, Sept. 20, 2018, about the state's new public pension law.

Follow more of our reporting on

See all 10 stories
  Comments