‘There’s nothing fragile about him.’ Cutter Boley unfazed by difficult UK football debut.
READ MORE
Preview: Kentucky vs. Auburn
Click below to read more of the Herald-Leader’s and Kentucky.com’s preview coverage ahead of Saturday’s Kentucky-Auburn football game at Kroger Field.
Expand All
Nothing about much-hyped Kentucky freshman quarterback Cutter Boley’s collegiate debut was ideal.
Rather than finding a soft landing space for Boley to play in a blowout win against lesser competition, the first opportunity for him to see the field during what is expected to be a redshirt season came in front of a hostile crowd at Florida with a Kentucky loss already assured.
On his first play, Boley threw an interception that was returned for a touchdown. He returned for one more possession, but tallied six straight incompletions to finish his debut 0-for-7 with one interception.
The former Lexington Christian Academy star was far from discouraged though.
“Of course as a competitor, getting out there, the result for my play wasn’t exactly what I wanted to be, but that’s unmatched experience,” he said Tuesday. “I mean, there’s few places in the nation that match up to just the environment of The Swamp, so it’s nice to get in down there and get those reps. I think those reps are gonna be invaluable in the future.”
When Boley committed to Kentucky he was rated as a five-star player in the class of 2025, making him UK’s highest-ranked prospect of the recruiting website era. Those ratings dipped when he reclassified to graduate a year early from LCA — he finished as a four-star prospect and the No. 24-ranked quarterback in the class of 2024 by the 247Sports Composite — but UK coaches’ enthusiasm about his potential was unchanged.
On signing day, recruiting coordinator Vince Marrow called Boley “the future of this program.” Georgia transfer Brock Vandagriff was signed to be the 2024 starter so Boley could have time to adapt to college football, but Marrow even left the door open to Boley impressing enough to play as a freshman.
While Boley showed off impressive arm strength in the late cameo at Florida, nothing about his debut suggests he is ready to unseat Vandagriff as the starter for a struggling offense, especially considering Kentucky’s pass protection problems.
But the 0-for-7 day does not change Boley’s long-term outlook, either.
“I feel bad,” offensive coordinator Bush Hamdan said. “I really do. I mean, anytime you are getting your feet wet for the first time, and to go out there and I put them in that situation, and to throw that interception, I went to him and just kind of apologized.
“... He wasn’t warmed up and all those things. But for us, we’re in a situation where we can play him in four games, in a bowl game. In this conference, you never really expect scores to get out of hand, and we felt at the end, it did. And we wanted to get his feet wet. We wanted to get him a couple drives to feel what it was like playing on the road in that kind of environment. And I think we accomplished that. And just unfortunate how the first play went.”
Kentucky football history suggests you cannot draw many firm conclusions about a much-hyped quarterback’s future based on his debut. The top three quarterbacks in program history in career total offense all experienced ups and downs early in their careers.
Tim Couch excited fans when he threw a touchdown pass as a freshman off the bench in the 1996 season-opening loss to Louisville, but three weeks later in his first start at Florida things went arguably even worse for Couch than Boley’s experience in Gainesville. That day, Couch’s first pass was also intercepted. He finished the game having completed just 6 of 18 passes for 13 yards in a 65-0 loss.
Jared Lorenzen was redshirted during his first season at UK in an era where players were not allowed to appear in any games and preserve their redshirt. He started immediately as a redshirt freshman in 2000, completing 22 of 34 passes for 322 yards and three touchdowns in his first appearance, but he also threw three interceptions in that game, including one in overtime that led to a Louisville victory.
Andre Woodson’s Kentucky debut came as a redshirt freshman off the bench in the 2004 loss to Ohio, arguably the most embarrassing defeat in Commonwealth Stadium/Kroger Field history. Woodson held his own, completing 6 of 11 passes for 72 yards, one touchdown and one interception that day, but he would not do enough to earn the full-time starting job for two more years.
The most-hyped in-state quarterback signees since that golden era of Kentucky quarterbacks offered plenty of reason for excitement in their debuts but never fully cashed in on that potential.
Former Highlands star Patrick Towles came off the bench as a freshman to complete all five passes for 71 yards and a touchdown on his first series in a 2012 loss to Mississippi State, but was injured later in the game. Towles is probably underrated given the quarterback struggles since his departure, but he eventually lost his starting job and transferred to Boston College for his final season of eligibility.
Former Conner star Drew Barker, the quarterback who unseated Towles, was intercepted on his third career pass as a redshirt freshman at Mississippi State in 2015 but bounced back to complete all six passes on his second drive. Barker opened the 2016 season as UK’s starter, throwing for 323 yards and four touchdowns in a shocking season-opening loss to Southern Miss but attempted just 19 more passes as a Wildcat due to a back injury suffered that day.
Couch, whose son played with Boley at LCA, has served as a mentor to Kentucky’s newest hyped quarterback. In the immediate aftermath of Boley’s debut, he made sure to bring up his own experience in The Swamp as a freshman.
“You can’t end up in a much better place coming out of the University of Kentucky than he did,” Boley said of Couch, the No. 1 pick in the 1999 NFL draft. “So just getting advice from a person like him really means a lot.”
Hamdan is no stranger to a big moment not going as planned, either.
As a player, he stuck around at Boise State despite losing the starting quarterback competition multiple times. When he was finally handed a start in his senior day game, Hamdan threw his own pick six on his first pass attempt.
“I obviously knew I was gonna be out there, so I think that’s a little different,” Hamdan said. “... He’s the best kid on the planet, and so it’s just we thought it was the right thing to do to get him in and to get him some action as much as we can in those situations. Was he ready? Was he warmed up? No. It happened like that. It was a gut reaction.
“I am happy we got him those reps. I think anytime you can get in there and learn from that, it’s a good thing, but obviously not the exact start that he maybe wanted.”
Boley can appear in three more regular season games and a possible bowl game without losing his redshirt. Given UK’s current form, only the game against Murray State looks like an obvious opportunity to get him in a game with a comfortable lead, but even that is no sure thing as Kentucky has played its FCS opponents closer than hoped at times.
Kentucky coaches have been consistent in their assessment that the offense’s struggles cannot be blamed solely on Vandagriff, due in large part to the pass protection problems, but there may come a point where Mark Stoops and Hamdan have to consider a quarterback change as a spark. For now, the most likely outcome of that scenario would be more reps for backup Gavin Wimsatt, who has played consistently in wildcat packages.
But if Boley is the future of the position, coaches will have to consider if getting him more experience is the best path forward. A full offseason in the weight room looks essential to the 6-foot-5, 214-pound Boley reaching his potential, though he said he has already made major progress since enrolling in January just from watching Vandagriff and Wimsatt every day.
“He’s not a fragile young man,” Stoops said. “Like, there’s nothing fragile about him, especially with his mind. He’s a strong kid, and he’ll learn from it. After the first play I think he settled in and he really ripped some balls, but he’s got to slow down a bit.
“He threw it really hard, and you know he can throw the football. It’s just like, slow down a little bit. And that just comes from experience and playing.”
Saturday
Auburn at Kentucky
When: 7:45 p.m.
TV: SEC Network
Records: Auburn 2-5 (0-3 SEC), Kentucky 3-4 (1-4 SEC)
Radio: WLAP-AM 630, WBUL-FM 98.1
Series: Auburn leads 27-6-1
Last meeting: Auburn won 29-13 on Sept. 26, 2020, at Auburn, Ala.
This story was originally published October 24, 2024 at 7:30 AM.
